The Staggers

The latest comment and analysis from our writers

21 October 2022

It’s fitting that a vote on fracking destroyed Liz Truss’s government

It sums up the self-harm of prioritising free-market principles above all else.

By India Bourke

How appropriate that, of the many issues that Liz Truss’s government has misguidedly championed, it is fracking that caused her premiership to finally implode. Shale gas drilling in the UK would not just be a threat to local health and safety; it would imperil the climate while doing next to nothing to improve our struggling economy. In fact no policy could better sum up the self-harm inflicted when free-market principles are placed above all else. Fracking would neither secure energy supply nor lower bills because of unfavourable geology. Even some industry insiders admit it. The International Energy Agency has warned that no new reserves of oil or gas must be exploited if climate change is to be stemmed. And environmental groups, including an impressive grassroots ...

20 October 2022

The Tories must stop believing the lie Liz Truss was elected on

The problem is hard Brexit: there is no growth model that will work under conditions of mutilated trade with Europe.

By Paul Mason

Liz Truss fell because she was elected on a lie. Not the kind of lie Boris Johnson routinely told – the blatant tactical fib – but the strategic lie, believed by millions of people and encoded in the textbooks: that the small state is the only route to growth and that redistribution is both economically and morally wrong. She clawed her way to the front of the Conservative leadership contest by repeating this doctrine without nuance. And 81,000 party members drawn from the white, suburban, selfish middle classes backed her because the lie is their gospel. Truss assembled a cabinet of randoms – mediocrities elevated by accident through the Tory careers system. Their only common feature was petty vindictiveness and belief in ...

20 October 2022

End this banana republic and call a general election

Britain did not sign up to three prime ministers in three months, a trashed international reputation and a broken economy.

By Martin Fletcher

“I’m a fighter, not a quitter,” Liz Truss declared during Prime Minister’s Questions on Wednesday. That was yesterday. Today she has resigned after just 44 days in No 10, the shortest-serving prime minister in British history. The “human hand grenade” has exploded faster than anyone thought possible. And so the Conservative Party will begin the process of picking its third leader, and Britain’s third prime minister, of the year – and the fifth in six years. It looks likely to prove a right old bunfight. The incompetent, narcissistic, dishonest Boris Johnson once again? Heaven forbid. Rishi Sunak? Penny Mordaunt? Suella Braverman? Kemi Badenoch? Ben Wallace? Any money on Jacob Rees-Mogg? The latter was only yesterday insisting that “this is a government ...

20 October 2022

Suella Braverman’s resignation letter reveals the extent of Liz Truss’s incompetence

It’s stinging to be called out for not being sufficiently serious by a Home Secretary who drivelled on about “the tofu-eating wokerati”.

By Peter Williams

“As a petty and vindictive individual,” explained Peep Show’s Mark Corrigan of his decision to invite a love rival to his party, “I have to take extra care not to appear petty or vindictive.” Which just goes to show that even solid, Tory-to-the-bone, averagely unhappy men like Mark can’t escape the sort of dangerously overt self-reflection encouraged by the liberal elite.  No such lily-livered introspection for the former home secretary Suella Braverman, who left high office completely of her own volition yesterday with a tour de force of passive-aggressive insinuation, blame deflection, and hull-splintering broadsides against a listing Prime Minister and government that she has, “with the greatest regret”, decided to no longer serve. Her resignation letter, evoking all the clenched-jaw serenity of ...

20 October 2022

Shows like The Rings of Power and She-Hulk have been runaway successes – why can’t keyboard warriors admit it?

Happily, these shows have proven to be huge hits – extremely popular with audiences and critics alike, despite the trolling.

By Marc Burrows

The great doom was foreseen from the moment the first trailers hit, the first images were released and the casting first announced. “This will be a disaster.” “This will end the studio.” “Fans have had enough”. Which show? Basically all of them. Critics on Twitter and YouTube said it about Amazon’s Lord of the Rings: The Rings of Power, they said it about Disney+’s She-Hulk: Attorney At Law, and they said it about Obi-Wan Kenobi. And these are just the most recent three. It was said they had been infected by woke agendas, had no respect for their respective source material and that fans would eventually realise. The emperor would be revealed in all his naked glory (thankfully, in the case ...

19 October 2022

Iran’s silencing of Elnaz Rekabi proves the protests are working

The champion climber competed without a hijab in Seoul, before walking back her protest online. But suppressing her bravery only fuels the movement.

By Ava Homa

Elnaz Rekabi is a champion for freedom-seeking Iranians, not only because of the medals she’s won in domestic and international climbing competitions, but because of her brave act of defiance. On 16 October, the 33-year-old athlete competed in the Asian Climbing Championships in Seoul without wearing a headscarf. Her exposed hair wordlessly shook the pillars of a government back home that has subjugated female bodies to establish its power. Aware that her decision to forgo a headscarf could endanger her future, she seemingly chose to support the loud and clear “NO” that protesters across Iran have been saying to the oppressive Islamic Republic of Iran (IRI) since 16 September. On that now historic date, a 22-year-old Kurdish woman called Jina ...

19 October 2022

Is the delay on social care reform such a bad thing?

Workers shouldn’t have to pay for pensioners’ care.

By Helen Barnard

When Prime Minister Boris Johnson unveiled his plan for social care last year, which is due to come into effect in 2023, there was no shortage of criticism. The best thing in it was a more generous means test, which would enable around 50,000 more people to access state-funded care each year. The cap of £86,000 on the amount anyone has to pay for care across a lifetime was a step forward but disappointingly low – with a last-minute change introduced by the then chancellor Rishi Sunak making it far less fair for those with lower levels of housing or other wealth. The Johnson government’s plans looked like they would do little to address the other significant problems in the ...

19 October 2022

What JK Rowling and John Cleese get wrong about cancel culture

A belief in accountability does not involve condoning threats or violence – and freedom of expression does not mean freedom from consequence.

By Billy Bragg

Last week, in an interview with Mariella Frostrup at Cheltenham Literature Festival, Graham Norton ventured that “cancel culture” is just another word for accountability. He referenced recent complaints made by John Cleese, who feels he is persecuted for his un-“woke” views. No one expects the Spanish Inquisition, eh John? When pressed on whether his idea of accountability included the abuse suffered by JK Rowling following her statements on trans women, Norton suggested that it might be more illuminating to talk to trans children and their parents, rather than merely amplifying the opinions of a celebrity or author – even a very good one.  I have long believed that what right-wing media call “cancel culture” is nothing more than the tendency of reactionaries to cry wolf ...