The Staggers

The latest comment and analysis from our writers

24 June 2024

Starmer and Sunak try to charm the readers of the Sun

The newspaper’s election showdown produced a hostile crowd.

By Nicholas Harris

Fielding an audience of Sun readers should be home turf for a Conservative leader: flash your fiscal discipline, flaunt your Euroscepticism, and get your law and borders out. But it’s hard to imagine Rishi Sunak ever picking up a copy – he seems more of a Forbes or Harvard Business Review man. Working this crowd is symbolic of his broader challenge: how to charm Red Wall voters and hold the 2019 Conservative coalition together? He was up against the Sun’s political editor Harry Cole, a genial host who manages to be burly and jaunty – a prop-forward with a cheeky grin and a sharp post-match suit. He had Sunak on the back foot from the off with the election betting scandal. ...

21 June 2024

The Washington Post drama reveals the myth of Americanisation

Britain’s distinct journalistic style is proof of its cultural independence.

By Finn McRedmond

The American newsroom is beset by anxious handwringing: slowly it seems the Brits are coming for every top job. The Wall Street Journal, CNN, Bloomberg News and the Associated Press are all now helmed by redcoats. Plenty of these appointments have been met with internal consternation (American suspicion of the Brits is an under-reported phenomenon), but none as much as the attempted appointment of the Telegraph’s Rob Winnett as editor of the Washington Post. The Post’s British CEO, Will Lewis, was already struggling to court the affection of his newsroom. With his bid to impose Winnett’s Fleet Street sensibilities on the place, he may have jeopardised his entire mission. Hiring Winnett should have been Lewis’s crossing the Delaware moment: Winnett is ...

21 June 2024

Labour can never win on TikTok

The party is at risk of losing its once-central cult of personality.

By Ella Dorn

For at least a decade, social media has played host to a particular stylistic affectation – we might call it “Brits online”. To be a Brit online is to perform a sort of relatable, makeshift crapness – the recreated inner world of a GCSE student on a rainy geography trip, or of someone curing a hangover at Greggs. On the open plain of the English-language internet, which springs from America’s flashy and ahistorical Silicon Valley, one must set themselves apart. Now we are in the midst of the first TikTok election, and the warring parties have fallen into the clutches of the very British meme. When it isn’t vlogging from the battle bus (Brits on tour!) the @uklabour TikTok account communicates ...

20 June 2024

Question Time Leaders’ Special: not even Starmer had a good night

As before, the Labour leader was weakest on the Corbyn question.

By Andrew Marr

The most remarkable takeaway from BBC's Question Time leaders' special was that Rishi Sunak didn't punch anybody. He looked very much as if he wanted to, clashing snippily with audience members (at one point getting shouts of "shame!" from those who disagreed with him over the European Court of Human Rights). But, he didn't actually whack a voter. As this disastrous election campaign careers on, the Prime Minister has developed what can only be described as an angry smile - both very angry and very smiley. He is under extreme pressure and must be close to blowing up. That he hasn’t lost it in public so far is a major endorsement for Hinduism. Sunak pitched particularly hard and most effectively to ...

20 June 2024

Why the Bank of England didn’t rescue Rishi Sunak

Andrew Bailey's announcement on interest rates was inescapably political.

By Will Dunn

Andrew Bailey, governor of the Bank of England and slayer of prime ministers, has just announced that the Bank will not be cutting interest rates just yet (the Bank rate is being held at 5.25 per cent) despite yesterday’s announcement by the Office for National Statistics that inflation has returned to its target level of 2 per cent. In doing so, Bailey has deprived Rishi Sunak of his last chance to take credit for some decent economic news before the election on 4 July. Not that a rate cut would have changed the outcome of the election. Most people either understand that reducing inflation is the Bank’s job, not the Prime Minister’s, or don’t understand that but also don’t feel any ...

20 June 2024

The aftershocks of Brexit aren’t over

After a conspiracy of silence, the European question will return to haunt the main parties.

By David Gauke

Brexit is the unspoken issue of this general election campaign. The Conservatives won the last election on “getting Brexit done” but now avoid drawing attention to what few consider to be much of an accomplishment. Nigel Farage seems to have reached a similar conclusion.  Labour wants the backing of those who supported Leave – “hero voters” they call them – as do the Liberal Democrats. To be fair, the latter have a policy to rejoin the single market but would rather not talk about it. In each case, there is a plausible political case for avoiding the topic but it is very odd. Brexit has redefined our politics and hugely affected the economy.  Nor will it be possible for political parties ...

19 June 2024

The SNP manifesto is a challenge to Labour

John Swinney’s party is outflanking Keir Starmer from the left on the NHS, welfare and the House of Lords.

By Chris Deerin

If anyone was in any doubt about what matters most to the SNP amid the various severe and generational crises facing Scotland, its general election manifesto immediately sets them straight. Its very first page states, in slightly screamy point size, “VOTE SNP FOR SCOTLAND TO BECOME AN INDEPENDENT COUNTRY.” There is also, however, an early indication of John Swinney’s attempts to restore the public image of his ailing party, with a promise that the subsequent pages contain “moderate left-of-centre policies” – the equivalent of a supermarket ingredients label. This message, this shift, is vital to the SNP’s pitch, and was re-emphasised by Swinney at the launch, when he said that “we are a moderate, left-of-centre party in the mainstream of Scottish ...

19 June 2024

Who’s really winning in Scotland?

A poll putting the SNP ahead has not stopped Scottish Labour increasing its number of target seats to the mid-30s.

By Chris Deerin

Either Labour are about to demolish the SNP’s long Scottish hegemony at this general election, or the nationalists will remain the largest party. Both outcomes cannot be true. Both have been predicted by recent polls. At the weekend, an MRP poll by Survation suggested the SNP would win 37 of the 59 Westminster seats on 4 July, putting them comfortably ahead of Scottish Labour and dealing a severe blow to Anas Sarwar’s hopes of becoming first minister in 2026. However, the eight other polls by seven different companies taken since the election campaign began, using the uniform national swing (UNS) model, have more commonly put Labour in front.  The party certainly believes it is winning, with sources suggesting this week that it ...