The Staggers

The latest comment and analysis from our writers

3 January 2024

Reform UK needs Nigel Farage back soon

The right-wing party’s heavily trailed press conference failed to live up to the hype.

By Rachel Cunliffe

It’s not often that a fringe party steals the news agenda, but funny things happen when Nigel Farage is (or is at least rumoured to be) involved.  In a packed (if rather soulless conference room) in a glitzy hotel in London Victoria, the tension was palpable. The big announcement of the press conference was to be Reform UK’s candidate in the upcoming Wellingborough by-election, triggered by the suspension from parliament of the Tory MP Peter Bone. Might Bone, who lost the Conservative whip in October, defect to Reform (founded by Farage in 2019 as the Brexit Party) and stand as their candidate? Or might Farage himself make an eighth attempt to become an MP? The Reform party leader Richard Tice was ...

3 January 2024

Labour must prepare for a grim inheritance

A stagnant economy and a fractious geopolitical climate won’t disappear with a change in ministers.

By Freddie Hayward

This may be the year in which more than a decade of Tory rule ends, when Keir Starmer could be in No 10, hosting cabinet, attending the National Security Council and negotiating with foreign powers. But what obstacles lie ahead? Business confidence and the government’s grip on parliament might be better under Labour but the country’s fundamental problems will be the same whoever wins the election. A stagnant economy, struggling public services and unstable foreign affairs won’t disappear with a change in ministers. The international context is growing more fractious. Conflict between states, as Adam Tooze notes, was rising even before the 7 October Hamas attack and Israel’s subsequent invasion of Gaza. This year will see elections in Pakistan, India, the US, ...

3 January 2024

Stop complaining about January – it’s the best month

It’s not the month you want, but it’s the one you need.

By Peter Williams

January is the best month of the year because January is honest. It doesn’t lie to you and it doesn’t let you lie to yourself. It starts not at midnight on New Year’s Eve – that tired final festive fling that no one needs – nor on the fug of New Year’s Day, when you might manage to struggle to the corner shop, dodging the broken glass and the strange quiet outside. No, it’s in your first week back at work, when you wake to hear the rain against the bedroom window, and it’s still dead-of-night dark, save for the light of your phone or your SAD lamp (which uses light therapy to imitate summer sunshine) that the month properly begins. Picture yourself ...

2 January 2024

The problem with Nicola Sturgeon wasn’t a “cult of personality”

Policy did trump personality under the former Scottish first minister – but the wrong kind.

By Chris Deerin

The “cult of personality” that forms around successful leaders is often criticised. And it makes for an easy target, especially once they’re gone. Mhairi Black, the firebrand SNP deputy leader, is the latest to take aim, saying today (2 January) that the focus on Nicola Sturgeon during the former first minister’s leadership left her “uncomfortable”. Black told Times Radio that Sturgeon’s departure from office was “quite healthy because I’m a big believer in politics should be about policy as opposed to personality”. There should have been greater focus on the wider independence movement, she added. “There’s a balance to be struck and I’m not convinced that we always got the balance right.” There are a few things to be said about this. ...

28 December 2023

Who owns the news?

The New York Times’ lawsuit against AI is a fight for the future of journalism.

By Will Dunn

The New York Times has become the first major media organisation to begin legal action against the use of its journalism by large language models and the “AI” chatbots, such as ChatGPT, on which they are based. In a lawsuit against OpenAI and Microsoft, filed in New York yesterday (27 December), the NYT claims that millions of its articles – products it spent “billions of dollars” creating – have been used to train the technology behind ChatGPT. On the one hand this seems like a fairly straightforward case: publicly available information confirms that the NYT was the largest privately owned component of the Common Crawl dataset – a “copy of the internet” that comprised 60 per cent of the data used ...

19 December 2023

Scotland looks closed for business

The SNP’s combination of high taxes and low economic growth is sending a negative message to the world.

By Chris Deerin

The Scottish budget began, as it always does under the SNP, with a prolonged whinge. There is not enough money, said Finance Secretary Shona Robison. This is all the Tories’ (read: the Union’s) fault. In the absence of complete control of the Scottish economy, she could only mitigate the damage inflicted by Westminster. Poor Shona, with her titchy £60m swag bag. Given the SNP’s preference for penal tax rates, it’s hard not to be grateful that her powers are limited. Even within her curtailed remit, Robison was able to introduce yet another new tax rate of 45 per cent on earnings between £75,000 and £125,140. The Scottish tax system now has six separate rates, introducing a heroic level of complexity. Further, ...

19 December 2023

How Rwanda ruined Rishi Sunak’s year

At today’s Liaison Committee session, the Prime Minister’s “tetchiness” was on display.

By Rachel Cunliffe

Given the choice, Rishi Sunak would probably have elected to skip today’s Liaison Committee session. It has been a harrowing few months for the Prime Minister, and ending the parliamentary year with a grilling from hostile select committee chairs was never going to be on his Christmas wishlist. The aim for prime ministers during such sessions is essentially to not make news. Don’t reveal anything you don’t want to reveal, don’t get caught in any traps, and don’t lose your cool at your fellow MPs. While the weekly Prime Minister’s Questions is a sparring match – where points are won with jokes and attack lines, and style can be used to outweigh substance – the Liaison Committee requires meticulous prepping and ...

14 December 2023

Nigel Farage is one to watch in 2024

Among the new Tory base, the former Ukip leader is more popular than most cabinet ministers.

By Ben Walker

Despite standing for election to the House of Commons seven times, and losing at every attempt, Nigel Farage is, arguably, the most successful British politician this century. As we noted in our recent Right Power List, which Farage topped, he has shaped government policy not only on Brexit but on net zero, small boats and “debanking”. Farage's recent appearance on ITV’s I’m a Celebrity... Get Me Out of Here! has prompted renewed analysis of his political prospects. But what do the public make of him? The former Ukip leader is generally more disliked than liked, by a wide margin. But he enjoys favourable ratings from three in ten British voters and, among Tory supporters, this favourability extends to a majority ...